ago. Store robbery is another way to get cash that's actually more trouble than it's worth. After killing Angelo Bronte in the mission "Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten," Dutch comes up with the plan to rob the bank in Saint Denis, which should give the entire group enough money to move to Tahiti and escape. Results & Consequences: If you follow him you will wake up in the cemetery or close to the river. Consequence. When I first made it to that town with the guy in the basement, I had no clue what I was doing. Saint Denis Bank robbery so easy it's a joke. Killing the lawmen driving the wagon will reduce Honor points by 5 for each lawman killed. Should have robbed a canned bean factory. Hey guys as you can see i got robbed for those guys. 5 seconds later, some guy breaks through the door and is like GET THE SHERIFF. But I guess that means its randomized. Here's a collection of Screenshots I have taken to show off the beauty of this game, it's truly incredible and I'm only on medium/high settings. ago. If you’re looking to get to Saint Denis in Red Dead Redemption 2, there are a few ways you can go about it. i got a worse one for ya. 1 yr. John however while actively killing and fighting off pinkertons, is only arrested. Pretty much the only way to spend that much money. Just got robbed $1k. . I did it with one other player and got a Gold medal on my first try. Arthur Morgan or John Marston can both visit this place in either the main game or in epilogue. Frankly. I believe I remember someone saying the alley is near the gunsmithIf you use lasso and/or punch him - non murder - i think you can get ur money back without the police getting involved. SirDiego • 5 yr. It won't light up so it's easily missed. I followed him and got knocked out and robbed. Rob Poker Game Gunsmith in St. 3 where Arthur gets roped into returning to Valentine to rob its bank by Karen, Bill and Lenny. Sell looted valuables at Fence (Extra Cash) Sell your valuable loot to the fence for cash instead of donating it to the camp’s tithing box. So couple of days ago I did the Saint Denis Robbery Tip for the gunsmith. Was riding on my horse when this guy who stood infront of an alley called me and said I could earn some money with him. i got a worse one for ya. Arthur Morgan. The Saint Denis bank robbery and police battle‐-----‐-----Mod used in the video:Bank robbery: ht. rdr2 saint denis bank robbery. I think a 2nd robbery is a glitch. After sneaking out, head back to Mr. Red Dead Redemp. 7k more. ago. When you get knocked out, they're gone. In the meantime - did y’all find the (I think it’s my first cheat code?) in the top drawer of a dresser in the Fence Shop in Saint Denis. Bridge in Bluewater Marsh north of Saint Denis. Besides the aforementioned items, you will also find a man. She sees Arthur losing faith in Dutch and uses him to help her get her family out. Bronte is a man of his word. The. Just got robbed $1k. Soon as i take the money out of the register. Get a tip from an NPC you rescued in a Random Encounter. I did the Saint Denis robbery flawlessly after about 4 attempts and only then did it clear from my task log. 🍁キ⃣ツ⃣ネ⃣🍁 Jan 9, 2020 @ 9:48am. Saint Denis Gunsmith Location Saint Denis Gunsmith Location in RDR2Part one. Put on a mask, run in, hold the gun on them until they open the cash register, grab it, then run outside and see if you can get to another Store before the Witness snitches on you (dont bother trying to stop/silence them in the middle of town), otherwise just ride away asap until you lose the law, go back and repeat. Sorry man. Online. Knock on it and this will unlock the option to rob the Saint Denis gunsmith side business. In this video. TimeSpecialist. The bank is a two story building with a large, decorated interior lobby. And for some reason Rockstar has decided, that in this scenario your horse dies if you die. We got it open! We paid $80AUD & this usually sells on eBay for $450-700! Never thought I'd own this :)RDR2 World Map. I decided to free him to try to re-lasso him and deag him from my horse- this was outside of town- of course the damn st denis police miraculously showed up and screwed everything up. I lost $1320, on the mission where you save John from sisika, and my last save was from 15% into the game. Red Dead Redemption 2. PSA. You can get the money back. Denis discussing the illegal poker game. It’s not possible to recover your money from the first two. Did you already know this? That's the. How to Rob the Cash Register in Any Four Shops in One Day for Bandit Challenge 3. -After the Bank, and after guarma, Abigail is immediately trying to get out. UPDATE: RDR2 Locked Box. I raged like hell when I saw there was no recent save available. Join. I had the opposite reaction—after getting robbed, it made me love the game even more. The second one they'll offer you goods for cheap (on the street right above the S in Denis) and you'll lose everything. In chapter 6, you can get robbed by three guys, one with a tall hat who leads you to them, promising guns and explosives. Bank Robbery: Charles. Light a man on fire and he's warm for his entire life. When the train doesn’t stop in Saint Denis as planned, the remaining gang members chase it down on horseback, resulting in the player. The guy asked me to follow him into a alley and i assumed it was a robbery. i don't remember exactly, but i did get my money back once, and then completely avoided that store entrance becuz it's a really stupid thing to throw at an outlaw. The same cannot be said for the Saint Denis robbery, which led to two deaths (including one of the gang's leadership) and an arrest, with zero money to show. There’s an illegal poker game happening inside the gunsmith’s shop in Saint Denis. I went immediately back and there was only a woman and man up on the balcony to the left when you go down the alley. 34 gold and $60. As soon as you reach the Guiteau Square, matchmaking will begin. Have never had a thieve knocked me out cold and lose $800 immediately and. I looked at the train robbery and Stagecoach missions along with bank are immersion only. Use the D-Pad to indicate you want to rob the upstairs. What made it disappear initially was because I did a side mission related to a letter you receive in your camp. The vault is only accessible by mission or glitch. The kid escaping was actually a surprise for me since I thought the mission just fails if you didn't catch the kid. Main missions are BY FAR the very fastest way to make money in RDR2. lost $1,000 and my last save was when my game was in 30% and i’m on 44% when it happened. Knock on it and this will unlock the option to rob the Saint Denis gunsmith side business. There’s an illegal poker game happening inside the gunsmith’s shop in Saint Denis. Required fields are marked. 2. Homie_2024 years ago#3. He doesn't search the camp, doesn't set up an ambush. Woke up at the Cemetery, went back and they weren't there. It can be tempting to finish missions as fast as possible, especially considering that looting every. So there are two. This robbery is doable without getting a bounty on your. I’m furies over this. Her lifeless body flopped onto the ground after Arthur's strong grip took the life out of her. cut to the chase. Chase them down with Lasso in-hand. Chu Ling is the gunsmith of the store and is seen running it by 1907. Get in the Stagecoach/Drive to the Bank. Crashing in saint denis bank robbery mission . I came back to life and was riding my way through the swamp and saw a cabin. So I got a little bit salty after losing all of $15 playing poker, so I did what any rational person would do. Having had enough of this I just shot the pickpocket in the head when he ran away. In this video. The game literally teaches you that you’re in control at all times, then slaps you on the nose with it. If you get robbed by the kids you get to meet them again and repossess it though. At any time, Arthur may spot a lawmen going after a thug. Saint Denis gun shop robbery done without alerting the po po, fun little side job wish I could rob these side business all day such a great addition to the g. Unlike most of the other towns, SD is highly Policed. You lose everything at the end of the main story but get your guns back after Epilogue 1 and all your money and more back after Epilogue 2. When you get knocked out, they're gone. Red Dead 2 Saint Denis Gunsmith Side Business. Robbed in Saint Denis. Robbed in Saint Denis -- Any way to get my money back? Question I followed a guy into an alley late at night to make some "quick money", knowing I was going to get jumped. Finally tackles the kid who steals your satchel in Saint Denis! 6. In between missions you might have to kill more to lower your Karma again. For a map of Saint Denis. However, they are already treated as side tasks. It was by the train track and across the street from the general store. You’ll lose some money, and all of your core meters will be in the red. Here's how to get it back: Go back to where you were robbed (this will be in the first alley north of the Saint Denis fence, next to the railway). I was riding towards the post office and a guy offered me some way to get quick money. This is one of the reasons I keep my bounty maxed in this region. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright. Now he wants to. During this random event Arthur is asked by a prisoner inside a wagon to help him get released. Just tried to rob the backroom game from the Gunsmith in Saint Denis. Go to the back of his store and you’ll see a locked metal door. Aiming at the. Join. 3. SUBSCRIBE BOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!rdr2, rdr2 movie, rdr2 cutscenes, rdr2 all cutscenes, rdr2 soundtrack, rdr2 trailer, rdr2 mods, rdr2 arthur dummy thicc, rdr2 a. Knock on the security door and the guard will tell you to leave. Anyone has any advice? (could not find any other advice than to rob the guy without a. So couple of days ago I did the Saint Denis Robbery Tip for the gunsmith. Woke up at the Cemetery, went back and they weren't there. The one in the alley in the little China town area in Saint Denis. Tips and Secrets - To brush up on things RDR2 doesn't tell you,. Where is he now? KalebShmaleb 4 years ago #1 I was riding my horse around Saint Denis then some posh looking guy with a. I have tried robbing gunsmiths, Doctor, and grocery side businesses a 2nd time on multiple play throughs with no joy. Whilst looking for a vampire in Saint Denis, the hero needs to pass through an archway that has the. I'm now an hour of gamplay after being robbed. 520. anyone know if I can get that back? Locked post. You can see it from roanoke ridge. While I walking around Saint Denis at night looking for something I saw someone call me over and asked if I wanted to make some money. after i sold some itens including a 300$ gold bar on a store in saint denis, i made my way to the gun store to make some engravings, next to the gun store an randon event hapenned, a guy in red called me offering a way to get easy money, i knew it would be an attempt of robery but i thought i would. Based on my thoughts, its probably up from $400 000, considering the fact that the bank possibly owns a lot of property, there's a sizable upper crust, lots of poor people, a good chunk of average wealthed folks, mortgages, loans and it. This shop is hiding a side-activity from which you can earn some extra money. Here's how to get it back: Go back to where you were robbed (this will be in the first alley north of the Saint Denis fence, next to the railway). Rdr2 Saint Denis Gunsmith Gone And Red Dead Redemption 2 St Denis Gunsmith Robbery is best in online store. Go to the back of his store and you’ll see a locked metal door. This event only happens in Saint Denis. Try it free. Where do you get money in St Denis rdr2? Sell looted valuables at Fence (Extra Cash ) You get lots of valuables by looting dead enemies. I think there are two different random encounters like this one in Saint Denis, where for one of them, you can recover your money, and for the other encounter, you lose your money permanently. Saint Denis Roof Access and for anyone who cares, i know i did, you can use the roof access points by the gunsmith to get into his secret robbery back terrace without doing it. Download this file. Robbery was a common occurrence in the Wild West, and is thus a major gameplay element in the Redemption saga. Took the train to Saint Denis, got there at nighttime, and got that interaction. 6. Fences are found at Rhodes, Saint Denis, Van Horn Trading Outpost. The gunsmith is of. But I guess that means its randomized. Ive lost all my money when I have tried it with less than 300$. When you get there, deal with the Aberdeens however you see fit. Bronte’s manor to meet back up with Dutch. The mystery of the Saint Denis vampire certainly fits into that category. Didnt know there was a safe in there. I didn't know you could catch him. Dude took 300 from me walking into van horn saloon. 1. If you don’t know how to open the locked metal door and rob. r/RDR2. So far nothing. Tried robbing the fence in saint denis. I thought that I might have a chance to fight back. Here’s how to go about getting your money back if you are robbed. Why the Saint Denis bank robbery wasn't the result of a rat (for anyone still confused) r/reddeadredemption • John is acting a bit weird, just wanna ask why. -Near the end of the main story, Milton rides into camp and nabs Abigail. This person, called Sonny, is one of a number of strangers in Red Dead Redemption 2. They ask Arthur if he has any cigarettes,. Also an escape route at the end. I just chased him til I caught him tbh. So, take a minute to rest and replenish your meters. •. 00 and did the limpany gold glitch and the Saint denis stable glitch and got myself 10 saves with a bunch of horses, I did itvfor the horses but figured I would grab a couple of bars. Red Dead Online Map. Went back to the scene of the crime, no one in sight. I catch up to him, I run right along side him, but I can't seem to do anything once I caught up. led. Just lost $1200. Got knocked out in the alley and lost $1200. Additional comment actions. You’ll lose some money, and all of your core meters will be in the red. I didn't think I would get nocked out, but I did. Boards. (Although sometimes even this one glitches and the muggers don't spawn). Complete within 5 minutes 30 seconds. Fortunately this did not happen to me but I did get robbed in Saint Denis when some guy is a dark alley said he had a money making venture. Open comment sort options. 17 comments. They are in post offices or train stations in Valentine, Rhodes, Strawberry, Saint Denis, Van Horn, and Armadillo. You can hunt him down and get more money back. He’s got the. First 5 minutes in Saint Denis after it got. Since getting the tip, the robbery's appeared in my log of tasks. Cleet is a street urchin and thief in Saint Denis. As soon as Chapter 4 opens, Dutch wants you to find Jack. When installed, the mod allows you to initiate a robbery simply by aiming your weapon at the teller. 0 coins. ago. Doctor – Valentine. Black, available at the Saint Denis Stable, or found in the encounter the OP mentions above. whenever you finish and robbery missions on cities, the best thing to do first is to pay. If you catch them in time you can kill them and get your money back. As such, try to rob people between towns in the vast landscape. 1 / 2. Red Dead Redemption 2. I immediately get into interrogating the guys into telling me about the money in the safe so the guy in front of it can unlock it. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. They only took $50 from me but I reloaded the last auto save anyway. It is located in Saint Denis in the state of Lemoyne and is close to the Saint Denis Police Department. In this video were going to the location and the best tips and tricks when it comes to shop robbery at saint dennis gunsmith & how to get away with as much m. lost $1,000 and my last save was when my game was in 30% and i’m on 44% when it happened. (Not that the game has any of those !)Yea like the whole police force of Saint Denis walking by like “that man has killed 95% of our police officers, was in our jail 642 times, slaughtered 234 innocent people on the street, robbed every store in our city at least twice, he’s wanted dead or alive in 4 states, and robbed our bank and killed 65 people during the robbery. #10. 01 in instead of 20. I could see the guy hiding and drew my gun thinking I could flip the robbery to my favor. ago. I have robbed the poker game above the St. In Red Dead Redemption 2 there are four stores that you can rob. There’s actually three different alley mugging encounters in Saint Denis. . New comments cannot be posted. - Place "BankRobbery. This walkthrough will guide you through all objectives of Banking, the Old American Art Main Quest including all Gold Medals for 100% completion. The task is to collect money from people who are in debt to Leopold Strauss. Today I learned not to bump into anyone at Saint Denis. Red Dead Redemption 2 is full of people to meet. This robbery is doable without getting a bounty on your. Killing the man results in a loss of 10 Honor points. I dont think you can find them. They take 25% of however much money you have and I’m pretty positive theirs no getting it back! The other night time robbery you can stumble into you can return the next night and kill em to regain all your money back but you have. Only the one north of the trapper allows you to get your money back by going back to the alley after waking up and killing the robbers. A skilled gunsmith operates this well-stocked store in Saint Denis's Chinatown. Arthur Morgan or John Marston can both visit this place in either the main game or in epilogue. ago. This shop is hiding a side-activity from which you can earn some extra money. Now that you know how to properly rob shops in RDR2, head to the location we have marked on our map. You can actually get the money back, they can be found at random locations in saint denis, I found them near chinatown. Rode all the way to the post office by the first fence paid it off, then some guy in the road stopped and said "hey I know you" I instinctively shot him and killed like 6 witnesses before one got away from me, bam $150 or so bounty there, rode back to Saint Denis and paid that, did the last mission for the artist, cops came and I had to shoot. RELATED: Red Dead Redemption 2 Mod Adds Giant. shamelesscreature • 19 min. The player can aim a weapon at an NPC and demand money. Only the one north of the trapper allows you to recover your money by going back to the alley where they ambushed you. If someone in Saint Denis says you wanna make some money fast. I had to open all 4 drawers. Saint Denis Alleys. Instead of losing just a portion of my money, I lost all 800 I had on me. We got it open! We paid $80AUD & this usually sells on eBay for $450-700! Never thought I'd own this :) RDR2 World Map. The. By Angie Harvey , Casey DeFreitas , Max Roberts , +1. If you go this route, hide the body, however. They consist of a wide variety of occurrences, from finding a. I ran upstairs to make my escape,only to find that the door. Nov 6, 2020 @ 4:52am. You can get your money back if you chase the guy and catch him and loot him. I’m not saying that you won’t incur a bounty but I am saying that, yes, you can get your money back. Pick a RDR1 character and a RDR2 character you’d want to see interact with each otherYeah I get that. Depends on the encounter. Post author: Post published: March 2, 2023; Post category:. He said it wasn't really legal and I followed him into an alley. Just got robbed in Saint Denis in front of Jade Dragon Restaurant . Does anyone know if shopkeepers in rdr2 respawn? I messed up the Saint Denis gun store robbery and killed the storekeeper, it’s been a while and he hasn’t respawned. Boadicea is so OP, 10 health, 9 Stamina, 7 speed & 6 acceleration. There’s an illegal poker game happening inside the gunsmith’s shop in Saint Denis. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Red Dead 2 Saint Denis Gunsmith Side Business. Each bar of gold will cost 500 dollars. 520 votes, 24 comments. Based on my thoughts, its probably up from $400 000, considering the fact that the bank possibly owns a lot of property, there's a sizable upper crust, lots of poor people, a good chunk of average wealthed folks, mortgages, loans and it. This robbery is doable without getting a bounty on your head. Players can hear Dutch complaining about his head injury several times during the remainder of the robbery, and his temper significantly worsens as the game progresses. It is located in Saint Denis in the state of Lemoyne and is close to the Saint Denis Police Department. So I just reloaded it. I have similar encounter, except when I enter the gun store. Knock on it and this will unlock the option to rob the Saint Denis gunsmith side business. r/RDR2. I have heard that if you go to an ‘L’ shaped building just above the last ‘S’ in ‘Saint Denis’ on the map you can find them and get the cash back. Le Tresor Des Morts is an extra mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 that's only available to those who pre-ordered the Special or Ultimate Editions of the game,. But allll the time when im up in the room, after i take the Money from the table i get a bounty and a bunch of policemans rushing the building. I was taking a walk one fine evening when I heard a guy pssting me to go to him. There are four backroom businesses that can be discovered and robbed to earn money and unlock weapons in Red. I have successfully questioned and threatened everyone in the room, taken the money from the table and the safe as well as everything else lootable in the room without killing anyone or alerting the law. You can actually get the money back, they can be found at random locations in saint denis, I found them near chinatown. If you enter the back door of the Saint Denis tailor, the thief waiting for you inside will act as shown in the video. Someone comes in. Business, Economics, and Finance. Hey, it's Ray! Links to highlights found below - First time playthrough of Red Dead Redemption 2 continues on with episode 6!by kids in Saint Denis, how to get the money back? So I was at the barber, walked out and at the entrance to the alleyway there were 2 kids with bear talking some shit, I scared them, they ran into alleyway. Yes you can get your money back, although the robbers might not be in the same spot, but definitely will remain in saint-denis, I found them near. If you catch them in time you can kill them and get your money back. These hunts are part of "A Better World, A. Note - After you get to the third chapter of the main story, the game unlocks subsequent fence missions. The vault is only accessible by mission or glitch. Red Dead Redemption 2into the alleyway heading west that sits just north of the Jade Dragon sign crossing the street. Same thing had happened once in valentine, and that went well, so I wasn't to concerned. If the player completes the mission as Arthur, Buell will be lost along with all the other horses owned by Arthur after the mission “Red Dead Redemption”. Loot Everything. 4. In Chapter 4 of Red Dead Redemption 2, you'll visit your first big town - Saint Denis. This is bullsh*t scripted event and if you die, you lose the horse. I followed him and got knocked out and robbed. The sheriff only paid me a random $11. I just got pick-pocketed and as I went to chase the guy down, an officer jumped in front of my horse and I got a bounty. It is the final mission of Chapter 4. Mod creator Jedijosh920 had the same idea when creating the Bank Robberies mod. Arthur meets Dutch and Lenny in an alley across from the trolley station. You could choose. I always go buy things I need first and then donate the rest to camp before turning myself into reset all the stupid high priced bounties. RELATED: Grand Theft Auto 6 Could Potentially Clean Up One RDR2 Mess Red Dead Redemption 2's Saint Denis Vampire ExplainedBanking, the Old American Art is the 57th main story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2). In order to perform it, you’ll have to open the locked metal door in the back of the shop. You still retain your saddle too. Respawn and see my money ticker go red for 268. aim at shop owner then press d pad up to ask him to open hidden door. Get in the Stagecoach/Drive to the Bank. I imagine the NPC just disappears and your money is gone if you lose him or don't give chase. I was very surprised to discover the intricacy of the game's random encounters 30 minutes later when the Dr. i lost 1500$. Required fields are marked. 00 even, you get the big gong sound instead of the ding sound Takes about 14-15 contributions per rank up If your unsure if you’re at cap make a save and dontate $20. I thought that I might have a chance to fight back. All because I ALMOST hit the fool with my horse. Then. To rob a train, players. Anytime I go to Saint Denis, I get robbed, pick-pocketed, people run in front of my horse like squirrels in the road. 110. Instead, I got knocked out from behind, and woke up in the saint denis grave yard $1,200 poorer. I GOT ROBBED OF $600 BY A PERSON IN SAINT DENNIS. Complete all the Main Story Chapters Missions and bring the tale of Dutch van der Linde's gang of outlaws to its natural conclusion. Silverfang37 4 years ago #1. 8. Must Be Dishonorable To Trigger The Mission. The only people I've ever gotten revenge on is the creepy ass hillbilly brother and sister who knock you. Doing the above made them all come right. Valheim Genshin Impact. Required fields are marked. 53. Stores in St. So I was at the barber, walked out and at the entrance to the alleyway there were 2 kids with bear talking some shit, I scared them, they ran into alleyway. But when I do Saint Denis gunsmith robbery silently, without lawmen on my tail or wanted level, I do get hunted by bounty hunters. There’s an illegal poker game happening inside the gunsmith’s shop in Saint Denis. Gold bars and other precious items can be sold at a fence; you can find them in Saint Denis, Emerald Ranch, Van Horn and Rhodes. I had the opposite reaction—after getting robbed, it made me love the game even more. Me doing the new low honor missions. is there any way I van get the money back from them? Nah you have to kill them when they draw on you, down the alley. 1. Our Red Dead Redemption 2 Chance Encounters Guide will help you all three types of Random Encounters in RDR2 with choices and outcomes of each encounter. I had level 4 arabian and just like everyone else, got ambushed outside Saint Denis. Everytime you steal from a store. You have to. I did that once when my bounty across 3 states added up to about 2,500 and was getting untenable lol. I just turned in a bounty for Lindsey Wofford in Saint Denis. He asked if I wanted to make some extra money and thought it was similar to the one in. Yes if you catch the pickpocket from the gun store or tailor, no if you follow someone into a dark alley and get. They killed both their parents and Momma is actually located upstairs in the Armoire. And a glass of water, sweetheart, my socks are on fire!" You can threaten them until they give you the money. RDR2 - What happens if you GET ROBBED with no money? #rdr2 #rdr #reddeadredemption. As soon as we went down a alley way a guy knocked me out and i wake up far away with my hat gone and 600 dollars stolen from me. It would be a logical thing to assume they would go and try to rob a bank. Once they Rob you you can go back to the house and get the money back. This page takes you through How to Rob the Cash Register in Any Four Shops in One Day For the third Bandit challenge in Red Dead Redemption 2. This allows you to quickly earn a few thousands of dollars, which you can use to buy new weapons, clothes or equipment for your horse. By Angie Harvey , Casey DeFreitas , Max Roberts , +1. Thinking I had a good hand I went all in with my previous winnings of about $12. Money Lending and Other Sins is a group of missions unlocked in Red Dead Redemption 2's second chapter. My encounter was at the gunsmith across from the church, for what it’s worth. My Red Dead collection minus a few items. Dutch was uncomfortable with it every step of the way and only went ahead with it because of Hosea's insistence. This page is dedicated to The Artist's Way, a quest in Red Dead Redemption 2 that consists of 4 phases. A Train Robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 is similar to coach robberies. If you mean getting pickpocketed by a guy bumping into you leaving the gun store, you can chase him down and get that money back. Some where near there is black Arabian horse which you can then stealI’ll look around for the guy in the robe. Go back to the same exact spot as quickly as possible, if too much time passes they’re gone forever.